Back to Investing

    The Best Brokerages for DIY Investors

    Educational content only. This article is for informational purposes and does not constitute personalized financial, tax, or investment advice. Consult a qualified professional for guidance specific to your situation.

    TL;DR

    • Best overall: Fidelity (ETF auto-invest, fractional shares, great app)
    • Runner-up: Schwab (excellent banking integration)
    • Transfer method: ACATS — tax-free, takes ~2 weeks, new brokerage handles it

    Quick Comparison

    SchwabFidelity ⭐Vanguard
    Low-cost investment productsYesYesYes
    Auto-invest into ETFsNo (mutual funds only)YesYes
    Fractional sharesLimitedYesYes
    Banking featuresExcellentExcellentBasic
    Customer serviceExcellent (24/7, branches)Excellent (24/7, branches)Lacking
    Mobile app / UIModernModernModern

    All three offer $0 trades and $0 account fees. You can't go wrong—but Fidelity edges ahead for most DIY investors.

    How to Transfer (ACATS)

    Open an account at your new brokerage, then ask them to initiate an ACATS transfer. Your investments move "in-kind" (no selling, no taxes). The whole process takes about two weeks. Cost basis info follows a few days later.

    Transfer to Fidelity Transfer to Schwab Transfer to Vanguard

    Try it yourself

    Advisory Fee Calculator

    See what advisory fees cost you over time and what a low-cost DIY portfolio could look like instead.

    Open the full calculator

    Enjoyed this? Get the next one in your inbox.

    New DIYFi guides and calculators, straight from the DIYFi newsletter. Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.

    Keep reading

    Leaving an advisor or have a complex situation? Book a free 15-min call.

    Curious how much you're losing to advisor fees? Try my fee calculator to see the 30-year impact.